Restaurants

Settlers Inn

4.4 118 reviews Closed W63N657 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012, United States

Discover this place

Settlers Inn, located in the heart of historic downtown Cedarburg, Wisconsin, is a gem that consistently receives glowing reviews from its patrons. Customers have raved about the generous portion sizes and the friendly, attentive staff, creating an inviting atmosphere that enhances the dining experience. Sami M notes the dishes are not only delicious but also reasonably priced, reinforcing the value offered at this establishment.

A standout item mentioned by M West is the crispy chicken sandwich, acclaimed as potentially the best in the state, available on select days. The dining options are flexible, offering both dine-in and carryout, making it suitable for varied preferences.

For those looking for a cozy space, Dana Carter describes Settlers Inn as uniquely comfortable and spacious—perfect for group lunches or intimate dinners. With a bar on-site, guests can enjoy a cocktail alongside their meal, adding to the overall vibe. The restaurant also provides catering services, as highlighted by Judy Munger, who praised their ability to accommodate specific requests with delicious food delivered punctually. Settlers Inn delivers not just meals, but heartfelt culinary experiences that keep customers coming back for more.

Overall, Settlers Inn triumphs in creating a warm, welcoming environment filled with home-cooked flavors and exceptional service.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Great coffee
Great dessert
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Historic

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Settlers Inn before visiting.

Reviews for Settlers Inn

4.4

118 reviews

100%

35%

Review highlights

Based on 118 reviews

Settlers Inn consistently receives praise for its high-quality, homemade food characterized by generous portions and flavorful dishes that resonate with both casual diners and those seeking a memorable culinary experience. The restaurant’s ambiance is often highlighted as unique, spacious, and comfortable, making it suitable for a variety of occasions from family gatherings to casual lunches or brunches with cocktails. Service quality stands out as warm, friendly, and attentive, with staff noted for accommodating special requests and catering needs. Additionally, the establishment’s location in historic downtown Cedarburg adds to its charm, offering both dine-in and carryout options with ample seating and a bar area. Overall, the combination of inviting atmosphere, consistent food excellence, and thoughtful service forms the core appeal of Settlers Inn among its patrons.

Sami M

Jul 08, 2025

Delicious! Nice size portions, worth the price. Staff was friendly and helpful.

M West

Jun 15, 2025

Probably the best crispy chicken sandwich you can get in the state when it's available on certain days. Really cool place in historic downtown cedarburg. They offer dine in or carryout, with ample seating and a bar.

Dana Carter

Jun 13, 2025

I have never had a bad meal here. I love their food!! It’s so heartwarming and delicious. I love the space — unique, comfortable, very spacious and perfect for lunch with a group/family or just a couple. I also love that they have a bar if you’re feeling like a cocktail with brunch, good coffee and such a great menu. I can’t say enough about this special place in Cedarburg.

Judy Munger

Jun 12, 2025

My family was very pleased with the lunch catering service from Settlers Inn for our mother's funeral. The food was delicious and delivered on time. Joan worked with us to create a meal that fit our wishes. I would highly recommend!

Bruce Danek

May 27, 2025

Very good home-made food. Awesome service

Charles Kay

May 12, 2025

Went for lunch with family. Prices were good and food was great . We had the Italian heros with fries and wife had the home made chips. The sandwiches were both full of flavor and both fries and chips were great . Daughter had a burger and fries also she loved it. Customer service was great and polite. We definitely recommend to stop in and have a bit. We definitely will be making a regular trip for lunches in the future. We done .

Emily Marthaler

Apr 07, 2025

Love this place!!! While enjoy a lot of what they offer - the best and most amazing are their pies!!!! Amazing crust reminds me of my grandmother and mother's! They are so good I served 30 of them at my wedding!

Krystal P

Mar 24, 2025

First time in Settlers Inn, and it was a great experience! Staff are extremely friendly, knowledgeable, and make great recommendations. I ordered two different fish fries with two different sides, and everything tasted delicious. Their tartar sauce was excellent too. I also had to try a piece of their German Chocolate Cake, and it was to die for! I cannot wait to go back and try more of their food.